Hawaiian residents, already anxious about months of nuclear sabre-rattling between US and North Korea, were sent into a panic
Hawaii: A Hawaii state worker mistakenly believed a ballistic missile attack was under way when he sent a false alert that rattled residents for 38 minutes until officials could find a way to send a correction, federal regulators said.
A worker on the day shift January 13 at the Hawaii Emergency Management Agency heard a message sent over a speakerphone by the night shift that erroneously included a live missile alert, including the words “THIS IS NOT A DRILL,” according to a summary presented at a Federal Communications Commission meeting in Washington on Tuesday.
Hawaiian residents, already anxious about months of nuclear sabre-rattling between US President Donald Trump and North Korea’s Kim Jong Un, were sent into a panic. The alert went out at 8:07am, setting off a chain of events that involved Hawaii’s governor, the military’s Pacific Command and Honolulu police, according to the summary prepared by the FCC’s public safety branch.
Operators hadn’t planned for responding to a false alert, and it was only after hurried calls that they agreed they could use the alert system to send a correction — which went out at 8:45am. In the meantime, one effort to reassure the public faltered as the governor, David Ige, lost his Twitter password, delaying his tweet until 8:24, or 15 minutes after being notified.
The worker who sent the alert was fired, and Hawaii’s emergency management administrator resigned, the Associated Press reported Tuesday.
The FCC’s investigation is continuing, and the agency wants to know what went wrong to avoid a repeat, said FCC Chairman Ajit Pai.
“Panic-stricken citizens called their families to say what they believed were their last words, and some even resorted to jumping into manholes to find shelter,” Pai said. “The only thing that struck the island was outrage — and rightly so.”
The FCC report offered details of the 38-minute period, including jammed phone lines at the emergency agency as citizens called, with some unable to get through, and a hurried meeting to determine a correction that met the criteria of a civil emergency message — one of the event codes used to initiate alerts. At 8:31am a worker logged into the system and created the correction messages that eventually were sent.
“Many things went wrong in Hawaii,” Pai said. “We simply need to identify the problems in order to fix them — not just in Hawaii, but anywhere else where they may exist.”
The now-fired Hawaii emergency worker had performance issues in the past.
Hawaii emergency management officials knew for years that the employee had problems performing his job.
The worker had mistakenly believed drills for tsunami and fire warnings were actual events, and colleagues were not comfortable working with him, the state said Tuesday. His supervisors counselled him but kept him for a decade in a position that had to be renewed each year.
The problems in the Hawaii Emergency Management Agency went beyond one troubled employee. The agency had a vague checklist for missile alerts, allowing workers to interpret the steps they should follow differently. Managers didn’t require a second person to sign off on alerts before they were sent, and the agency lacked any preparation on how to correct a false warning.
Hawaii Emergency Management Agency Administrator Vern Miyagi resigned as the reports were released. Officials revealed that the employee who sent the alert was fired on Friday. His name has not been revealed. A second worker quit before disciplinary action was taken, and another was being suspended without pay, officials said.
“The protocols were not in place. It was a sense of urgency to put it in place as soon as possible. But those protocols were not developed to the point they should have,” retired Brigadier General Bruce Oliveira, who wrote the report on Hawaii’s internal investigation, said at a news conference.
A Federal Communications Commission report revealed Tuesday that the worker who pushed out the alert thought an actual attack was imminent. It was the first indication the alert was purposely sent, adding another level of confusion to the misstep that created panic at a time of fear over the threat of North Korean missiles.
The worker believed there was a real attack because of a mistake in how the drill was initiated during a shift change, according to the FCC, which regulates the nation’s airwaves and sets standards for such emergency alerts. The employee said he didn’t hear the word “exercise” repeated six times, though others clearly heard it.
There was no requirement to double-check with a colleague or get a supervisor’s approval before sending the warning statewide, the federal agency said.
“There were no procedures in place to prevent a single person from mistakenly sending a missile alert” in Hawaii, said James Wiley, a cybersecurity and communications reliability staffer at the FCC.
Compounding the issue was that the state Emergency Management Agency had no prepared message for a false alarm. The FCC criticised the state’s 38-minute delay in correcting it.
In addition, software at the Hawaii agency used the same prompts for both test and actual alerts, and it generally used prepared text that made it easy for a staffer to click through the alerting process without focusing enough on the text of the warning that would be sent.
“The reports from the FCC and the state of Hawaii demonstrate systems and judgement failures on multiple levels, and they reinforce my belief that missile alerts should be handled by the federal government,” said US Senator Brian Schatz, a Democrat from Hawaii, who plans legislation to give federal officials that sole responsibility.
The FCC said the state emergency agency has taken steps to try to avoid a repeat of the false alert, requiring more supervision of drills and alert and test-alert transmissions. It has created a correction template for false alerts and has stopped ballistic missile defence drills for now.
Earlier this month, the worker who sent the alert heard a recorded message that began by saying “exercise, exercise, exercise” — the script for a drill, the FCC said. Then the recording used language that is typically used for a real threat, not a drill: “This is not a drill.” The recording ended by saying “exercise, exercise, exercise.”
Once the employee sent the false alert, he was directed to send a cancel message but instead “just sat there and didn’t respond,” the state report said. Later, another employee took over the computer and sent the correction because the worker “seemed confused.”
Gov. David Ige was asked why Hawaii didn’t reveal details about the employee earlier, and he said it would have been irresponsible to release statements before the investigation was complete.
Ige has asked the Hawaii National Guard’s deputy commander to prepare another report on what needs to be changed in the emergency management system overall. The first version of that report is due in two weeks, with a final version due in six weeks.